
In Pope Leo XIV’s original hometown of Dolton, Ill. — one of the small towns outside Chicago absorbed into the Chicagoland sprawl — three would-be carjackers ambushed an off-duty Cook County Sheriff’s deputy and his wife and child at a gas station on Feb. 19, 2023.
They threatened the surprised deputy at gunpoint, took his sidearm, and declared their intent to make off with his Dodge Challenger. But the deputy’s wife and children began exiting the vehicle, and the perpetrators abandoned the attempt and fled in their own vehicle.
More than three years later, on Thursday, April, 2026, Javon Stingley, 28, of southwest suburban Midlothian, was sentenced to five years and 10 months in federal prison over the incident, by U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis.
= Related Links =
- Attempted Carjacking at Suburban Chicago Gas Station Leads to Nearly Six-Year Prison Sentence – U.S. Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Illinois
- Suburban Chicago man sentenced in attempted carjacking of off-duty Cook County deputy – Fox 32
- Man sentenced to nearly 6 years for attempted carjacking of off-duty Cook County Sheriff’s deputy and his family – CBS
- FBI offers $10,000 reward for information on Chicago area carjacking suspects – WGN
- [2024:] $10K reward offered for conviction of 2 Chicago carjackers – Fox 32
- [Wanted By the FBI:] Gary Luellen: Conspiracy to Defraud the United States; Motor Vehicle Theft – Carjacking; Violent Crime/Drugs/Machine Gun
Michael Banks, 23, of Chicago, has confessed as part of a broader plea agreement in November that also encompasses three other carjackings and firearms offenses. Banks faces sentencing on June 24.
However, the alleged third perpetrator, Joseph Smith, 34, from Hammond, across the border in northwest Indiana, has pleaded not guilty to the incident, and other carjackings, and still awaits trial.
Nearly two years ago, in September 2024, it was reported that the FBI was offering a $10,000 reward for information leading to the arrest of Javon “JaJa” Stingley and another carjacking supsect, a fourth person named Gary “Lil Bird” Luellen. The latter is wanted in connection with a 2022 carjacking in Chicago itself, and it appears that Luellen is still at large and wanted by the FBI.
The attempted Dolton carjacking, in the 1000 block of E. Sibley Blvd., appears to have been within about two miles of Pope Leo XIV’s childhood home at Pope Leo XIV Childhood Home, 212 E 141st Pl.
= Press Release =
Attempted Carjacking at Suburban Chicago Gas Station Leads to Nearly Six-Year Prison Sentence
U.S. Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Illinois
CHICAGO — A man has been sentenced to nearly six years in federal prison for attempting to carjack a vehicle at gunpoint while the driver’s wife and children were inside.
The attempted carjacking occurred on the afternoon of Feb. 19, 2023, at a gas station in Dolton, Ill. An off-duty Cook County Sheriff’s Deputy was standing next to his Dodge Challenger when JAVON STINGLEY and two other men — JOSEPH SMITH and MICHAEL BANKS — approached with loaded handguns and demanded the vehicle. One of the carjackers said words to the effect of, “I’ll shoot you, don’t move,” and removed the Deputy’s service weapon from his waistband. The Deputy’s wife and children were able to flee the Challenger before the men started to get inside. The men decided not to take the Challenger and drove off in their own vehicle.
Stingley, 28, of Midlothian, Ill., was arrested in October 2024 and has remained in law enforcement custody since then. He pleaded guilty in federal court last year to an attempted carjacking charge. On April 9, 2026, U.S. District Judge Sara L. Ellis sentenced Stingley to five years and ten months in federal prison.
Banks, 23, of Chicago, admitted his role in the attempted carjacking as part of a plea agreement that included other carjackings and firearm offenses that he committed. Banks is scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Ellis on June 24, 2026, at 10:15 a.m.
Smith, 34, of Hammond, Ind., has pleaded not guilty to the attempted carjacking as well as to other carjackings and firearm offenses for which he is charged. Smith is awaiting trial.
Stingley’s sentence was announced by Andrew S. Boutros, United States Attorney for the Northern District of Illinois, and Douglas S. DePodesta, Special Agent-in-Charge of the Chicago Field Office of the FBI. The government was represented by Assistant U.S. Attorney Elie Zenner.