COLLEGE FOOTBALL RANKINGS 10.18.26 – Fighting Irish remain in top-4 after controversial would-be “loss” at BYU amidst game pock-marked with irregularities

U.S. map adapted from epa.gov image

= Jump to Rankings =

The (technically unofficial) “College Football Playoff” (CPF) declares, “Notre Dame receives an automatic bid if it is ranked in the CFP Top 12 on Selection Day. If so, six (6) at-large bids would be awarded.”

The first 2026 CFP rankings come out Tuesday, Nov. 3, issued by the College Football Playoff Selection Committee. Final rankings on Selection Day will be announced Sunday, Dec. 6, 2026.

Football on Sunny Turf, adapted from ,gov imageIt was a chaotic weekend that saw 5 of the previous top-7 teams tagged with losses. Previous-#1 Georgia dropped to #5/4 after losing to unranked Auburn; previous #5/4 Indiana dropped to #6 after losing to then-#4/5 Ohio State, who themselves then climbed to #3/2; previous #6/5 Alabama plummeted to #13 after losing at #14 Tennessee; previous #7/6 Texas also dropped like a stone, to #19/18 after losing to Florida.

Then-#2 ‘Notre Dame,’ the presumptive new-#1 after Georgia lost earlier in the day, found themselves in a somewhat UFO-like game in Provo packed with irregularities — if not outright cheating by BYU, if not by Big 12 officials themselves.

It was a would-be “regulation” game that technically, on the field, was never actually allowed to finish.

With time still left on the clock, with the clock stopped, and the Irish due for a 2nd and goal at the 8, Big 12 officials simply declared the game over.

Onlookers were, perhaps, still distracted by the stunning, baffling, and illegal non-call, on the previous play, of blatant BYU pass interference in the end zone, one of many non-calls, bad calls, or general irregularities throughout the game.

Yet with the record books, perhaps falsely, registering a would-be Irish loss, ‘Notre Dame’ dropped from #2 to #4 in the AP, and to #8 in the Coaches Poll.

College Football Rankings

AP/Coaches – Team (1st Place Votes) – Record – AP/Coaches Change – Most Recent – Next Up
[‘ND’ & Irish opponents boldface]

#1/1 Miami (Fla.) (40/50) 7-0 … +2/+2 … beat Florida State 43-35 … next: Pitt
#2/3 BYU (20/10) 6-0 … +6/+5 … “beat” #2 Notre Dame 28-24 … next: @ UCF
#3/2 Ohio State (9/13) 6-1 … +1/+3 … beat @ #5 Indiana 19-15 … next: bye week
#4/8 Notre Dame 6-1* … -2/-6 … “lost” @ #2/3 BYU … next: bye week
#5/4 Georgia 6-1 … -4/-3 … lost to Auburn 27-24 … next: bye week

#6/6 Indiana 6-1 … -1/-2 … lost to #4 Ohio State 19-15 … next: @ Michigan
#7/7 Ole Miss 5-1 … +2/+3 … beat #13 Missour W31-3 … next: @ #19 Texas
#8/5 Texas Tech 6-0 … +2/+4 … beat Arizona State 53-25 … next: @ Cincinnati
#9/10 UCLA 6-0  … +3/+2 … beat Wisconsin 17-7 … next: Michigan State
#10/9 Utah 6-0  … +1/+2 … won @ Colorado 27-24 … next: #14 Houston

#11/11 Tennessee 6-1 … +3/+3 … beat #6 Alabama 26-10 … next: @ South Carolina
#12/12 Kentucky 6-1 … +3/+5 … won @ Oklahoma 21-13  … next: Vanderbilt
#13/13 Alabama 5-2 … -7/-6 … lost @ #14 Tennessee 26-10 … next: Texas A&M
#14/16 Houston 6-1 … +6/+2 … beat #18 Oklahoma State 35-32  … next: @ #10 Utah
#15/14 Iowa 5-1 … +2/+2 … bye week … next: @ Minnesota

#16/15 Southern Cal 6-1 … +3/~ … bye week … next: @Wisconsin
#17/19 Wake Forest 6-1 … +4/+4 … won @ California 41-7 … next: bye week
#18/17 LSU 5-2 … +4/+4 … beat #16 Mississippi State 31-0 … next:  @ Auburn
#19/18 Texas 4-2 … -12/-12 … lost to Florida 27-24 … next: #7 Ole Miss
#20/24 Florida 5-2 …. NR/NR … won @ #7 Texas 27-24 … next: bye week

#21/22 Boise State 5-1 … +2/+2 … bye week … next: @ Washington State
#22/21 Missouri 5-2 … -9/-8 … lost @ #9 Ole Miss 31-3 … next: bye week
#23/20 SMU 5-1 … +1/+2 … beat Virginia 23-13 … next: California
#24/23 Northwestern 5-1 … +1/NR … won @ Michigan State 24-21 … next: Rutgers
#25/NR Arizona 5-1 … NR/NA … bye week … next: Iowa State
#NR/25 Oregon 4-2 … NA/~ … beat Nebraska 17-14 … next: @ Illinois

AP also receiving votes: Oklahoma State 128, Oregon 79, Auburn 61, James Madison 52, Mississippi State 30, New Mexico 6, Oregon State 3

AP dropped out: Mississippi State 16, Oklahoma State 18

Coaches Poll also receiving votes:
 Arizona 141, Oklahoma State 87, James Madison 80, Auburn 55, Mississippi State 32, Nebraska 19, Oregon State 17, New Mexico 16, UTSA 13, Michigan 10, North Dakota State 8, Wisconsin 7, Duke 7, North Carolina 5, Pittsburgh 4, Air Force 3, North Texas 1

Coaches Poll dropped out: Mississippi State 19, Oklahoma State 20


Regarding the unofficial ““College Football Playoff” (CPF),” as mentioned above, the Irish get an automatic bid if they are in the top-12 of the final selection-process rankings issued by the College Football Playoff Selection Committee. The CFP rankings start coming out Tuesday, Nov. 3 and the final rankings, used for actual bracket selections, will be on Sunday, Dec. 6, 2026.

Last year, of course, the Irish clearly qualified for selection under the old rubric, yet the rankings simply got reshuffled in a manner that arbitrarily shoved them out of contention, inexplicably and late in the process.Sp the question remains, this year, even if ‘Notre Dame’ seems to be on track to stay in the top 12 of those yet-to-be-initiated rankings, could they gravitate close enough to the bottom of the top-12 to be nudged out with a late reshuffling.

As for ‘Notre Dame’ vs. BYU, with time still left on the clock and the Irish coming up on a 2nd and goal at the 8, Big 12 officials inexplicably declared the game over — following a non-call of blatant BYU pass interference in the end zone the previous play.

Irish QB CJ Carr, throwing into double-coverage, lofted an NFL-quality pass, with near-perfect timing, touch, and accuracy, towards WR Jaden Greathouse heading to the back corner of the end zone. The only two possible results were that Greathouse would likely make the catch, behind and away from the BYU defenders, for an official win, or that BYU would commit pass interference, as their habitually dishonest DB’s had done many times throughout the game without being called.

Once the Irish seemingly realized that they were dealing with unreliable officiating, they started making catches in spite of pass interference, even while being mugged.  In this case, one of the dishonest BYU defenders grabbed Greathouse more vigorously, keeping him from making a play on the ball, with no flag.

That egregious non-call, on what the officials also falsely deemed the final play, was one of many non-calls or bad calls across a game pock-marked with a multiplicity of BYU cheating or irregularities, sealed by the Big 12 officials. One can only estimate the point differential resulting from the cheating and officiating.  At a minimum the differential was 3 to 8 points, given the officials casting a spiking of the ball as a fumble, yet likely the differential from cheating and bad officiating was much more than that.

One of Notre Dame’s multiple contributions to the rule book over the years has been the fact that a game cannot end on a penalty.  So, had the Big 12 officials been honest and competent, it would not have mattered if time had run out.  If BYU simply kept committing pass interference, or other penalties, ordinarily the Irish would just keep getting more plays and more opportunities. And the Irish, in fact, already had demonstrated multiple times that BYU playing dirty or dishonestly was not going to stop them from making catches.

So the officials failing to make the call might have meant, in their eyes, the opportunity to let time run out as well, and to try to avoid the fact that a game cannot end on a penalty.

Unfortunately for them, when the ball hit the turf, there was still time left on the clock as it is, one second, yet still time on the clock. Yet, with the Irish coming up on a 2nd-and-goal from the 8-yard-line, the Big 12 officials declared it was time to go home.  That was in addition to them failing to call pass interference the previous play.

The Big 12 conference, of course, supposedly would come out on Sunday declaring that the game had not actually been over.  What that means for the game’s status as a would-be regulation game, and the authority to declare its would-be result “official” is another matter.

Good luck trying to find the statement, however. The Big 12 did not appear to post it in any obvious place on their website, nor did they post it on their official twitter/X profile.

At the same time, by pretending to have addressed the game’s problems, but then seemingly focusing on only the clock issue, the Big 12 tacitly set up a rhetorical smoke screen to obscure the legion of other problems.  In other words, in a game sabotaged by many problems, the Big 12 pretended it was looking into the game, then perhaps acted like the only issue was the clock.

The Irish now have a bye week before traveling to play Navy at a neutral site, followed by ‘Notre Dame’ hosting current-#1 Miami (Fla.) in The House That Rockne Built.

The bye week is fortuitous and timely, considering that the less-than-complete game in Provo was a night game, and the university is notorious for ignoring the science regarding sleep disruption and having their football student athletes tag red-eye flights back right after long-distance night games.

At least one of the modern Irish losses to tenacious Navy came after a red-eye flight. And a red-eye flight back from Provo undoubtedly will at least partially undermine both the team’s studies and their athletic training across the coming days.  Yet hopefully having two weeks to get ready for Navy will help mitigate all that.

Both the AP College Football Poll and the U.S. LBM Coaches Poll, of course, are unofficial. Although for many years they were looked to as a source of the “mythical” Div. I-A/FBS national championship. Back in the day, of course, the Coaches Poll was usually known as the UPI Poll

Technically, the cable TV-sponsored, would-be “College Football Playoff” is also unofficial, merely a post-season tourney receiving cooperation from the conferences. For a while, it had a practical relevance because it tended to include most of the best teams, in an elimination bracket — until last year, when the best team in college football was actually excluded, undermining the tournament’s credibility as a hypothetical, would-be “playoff.”

Football on Sunny Turf, adapted from ,gov image

U.S. map adapted from epa.gov image

University of 'Notre Dame' Library with Christ with Arms Upraised

'We're #1 Moses Sculpture by Ivan Meštrović, next to Hesburgh Memorial Library; photo and editing (c) Steven C. Welsh

University of 'Notre Dame' Stadium Facade with engraved name and fans

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *